---
title: Footsteps from Above
url: https://oosioo.com/en/p/%EC%9C%84%EC%B8%B5%EC%9D%98-%EB%B0%9C%EC%86%8C%EB%A6%AC
date: 2026-11-16T11:00:00+00:00
author: SYSOP
summary: The notebook asked: what would be the wisest way to reconcile two households at war over inter-floor noise? Korean apartments saved storey height and construction cost by removing the columns and letting the walls carry the building — and those walls became roads for the upstairs footsteps, which now ring from the entire downstairs ceiling. 98.5% of large apartment complexes completed over a decade were wall-bearing. I trace why cushioning layers fail against a child's 63 Hz footfall, how much a thicker slab actually buys, how the floor-impact rules chased the noise for twenty years and where they have stalled; the wave of inter-floor noise films that filled Korean screens last year; the grade-1 floors the builders are racing to make; and the AI research that names a noise with 95% accuracy, locates it, and measures it with vibration sensors instead of microphones. A floor-lab playground lets you rebuild the floor and hear the difference. The thirty-sixth piece in A Page for Today.
---
# Footsteps from Above

![On a dark concrete-grey background, the left side reads "A Page for Today · 36", the large title "Footsteps from Above" and the line "The moment Korea removed the columns and let the walls carry the building, the upstairs footsteps became the entire downstairs ceiling. Designing reconciliation in a country where 98.5% of apartments are wall-bearing." Tags read "Walls that carry the house", "63 Hz heavy impact", "49 decibels", "Noise turned cinema" and "AI that names the sound". On the right is a cross-section of two apartment floors, with ripples showing an impact on the upper floor spreading through the walls into the flat below.](/uploads/44e5a032ee94dd88.webp =720)

Today the notebook held a single question.

> What would be the wisest way to reconcile two households at war over inter-floor noise?

There is no date next to it, but I can guess what kind of day it was written on. It would have been a night when a thud, thud came down through the ceiling. In Korea, 53.1% of all households live in apartment blocks (2023 Population and Housing Census). Counted by housing stock, 79.2% of homes are in multi-unit buildings. So this is a question that could be asked in any home in the country.

Reading it again, though, something about the question feels off. To reconcile two warring households, you first have to understand why they went to war. And this war usually isn't started by anyone being unreasonable. The upstairs family walked at an ordinary pace, and the downstairs family really did hear thudding. Neither of them lied, and still there is a fight. We need to start with the third party standing between them: the building.

## A house held up by walls

For a building to stand, it needs a skeleton that carries its weight down to the ground. There are broadly two ways. A column (rahmen) structure stands columns and spans beams between them to carry the floors; a wall-bearing structure has no columns or beams, and the walls themselves take the load. There is also an in-between type, the flat plate, where columns support the slab directly without beams. Office buildings are mostly column structures — you need to be able to knock the walls about. Korean apartment buildings are overwhelmingly wall-bearing.

How overwhelmingly? According to data the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport submitted to the National Assembly, of the 1.97 million units in complexes of 500 or more households completed nationwide between 2007 and June 2017, 1.94 million — 98.5% — were wall-bearing. Among privately built apartments alone, 99.3%. In 11 of the country's 17 provinces and metropolitan cities, every single large complex completed in that period was wall-bearing.

The reason is simple: cheaper, faster, and more units. A column structure needs beams running under the ceiling, so each storey is at least 30 cm taller than in a wall-bearing building, and industry figures put its construction cost 10–30% higher. With no beams, a wall-bearing building can squeeze an extra floor or two under the same height limit. In 1988 the government announced its plan to build two million homes — a third of the nation's entire housing stock at the time — and the next year the five first-generation new towns of Bundang, Ilsan, Pyeongchon, Sanbon and Jungdong broke ground at once. The wall-bearing slab apartment suited that race, and it became the standard Korean apartment.

The price came in several instalments. Load-bearing walls cannot simply be knocked through, so remodelling decades later is hard, and the pipes are buried in the floor, so repairs are hard too. And the moment a wall becomes structure, the wall becomes a road for sound.

![On the left is a cross-section of two floors of a wall-bearing apartment. There are no columns or beams; the walls directly support the floor slabs, and ripples and arrows show an impact on the upper floor travelling through the slab into both walls and spreading into the lower flat's ceiling and walls. On the right is a column (rahmen) structure, where columns and beams support the floor and the impact gathers into the beams and columns, radiating over a much smaller area into the room below. Captions read "Wall-bearing: floor vibration travels the walls into the flats below and beside" and "Column: vibration disperses into beams and columns".](/uploads/60a73bf6b6d5d648.webp =720)

## The thud travels the walls

Inter-floor noise is not sound carried by air. It is structure-borne sound: an impact on the upstairs floor shakes the concrete frame directly, and that vibration turns back into sound at the downstairs ceiling and walls. This is why wall-bearing structures are at a disadvantage. The floor slab is cast as one body with the load-bearing walls on every side, so the floor's vibration runs down the walls and sideways into the neighbouring flats. In a column structure, much of the vibration funnels into the narrow path of beams and columns. In the words of the lawmaker's office that published the 98.5% statistic at the 2017 parliamentary audit, a wall-bearing building "has no effect of dispersing vibration through beams and columns".

Floor impact sound is measured in two kinds. Light impact sound comes from light, hard shocks — a dragged chair, a dropped toy. Heavy impact sound comes from heavy, soft shocks — children jumping, an adult walking on their heels. The complaints are about the latter: by the Ministry of Environment's tally, 68.6% of inter-floor noise complaints from 2020 to July this year were about "the sound of running or walking".

The trouble is that heavy impact sound is low-frequency. The 63 Hz band at the centre of its rating has a wavelength of over five metres. Sound like that is fundamentally hard to block with objects. A Korean apartment floor is a floating floor: a resilient cushioning layer laid on the slab, topped with lightweight foamed concrete and finishing mortar. This build-up works well against light impacts, but it does something perverse with heavy ones. The floor layers sitting on the cushion behave like a mass on a spring, resonating at particular low frequencies. Measurements show that EPS (styrofoam-type) cushions resonate — of all places — near 63 Hz, and EVA cushions near 125 Hz. There are documented cases where laying a cushion made the thudding louder. The downstairs ceiling plays the same trick. In one building-materials company's experiment, finishing the lower flat's ceiling with a 200 mm air gap cut light impact sound by 3 dB but amplified heavy impact sound by 6 dB. The air in the ceiling rang like a spring.

![A cross-section of a Korean floating floor. From the bottom: concrete slab 210 mm, resilient layer 30 mm, lightweight foamed concrete 40 mm, finishing mortar 40 mm, and the floor finish, stacked in layers. On the right is a drawing of a weight on a spring, with notes reading "The floor layers on the cushion behave like a mass on a spring — EPS cushions resonate near 63 Hz, EVA near 125 Hz" and "It blocks light impact (high frequency) well but passes or even amplifies heavy impact (low frequency)".](/uploads/173a96a90ef3c9fe.webp =720)

So what does work? The mass and stiffness of the concrete. The thicker and heavier the slab, the less it shakes under the same blow. By the LH housing research institute's figures, thickening a slab from 150 mm to 210 mm buys about 5 dB. Beyond that, the returns collapse: a review by the Korea Institute of Civil Engineering and Building Technology (KICT) and KAIST, quoted in the press, found that going from 210 mm to 240–270 mm cuts heavy impact sound by a mere 1.5 dB — or amplifies the low frequencies. Changing the structure is more decisive: on identical 150 mm test slabs, the wall-bearing structure measured 58 dB and the rahmen structure 53 dB. But KICT's 2024 literature review also recorded a humbling result. When residents were surveyed, those living in wall-bearing buildings and those in column or flat-plate buildings perceived their sound environment about the same. Changing the structure does not automatically deliver a quiet home.

In the playground below you can rebuild the floor yourself. Choose the structure, slab thickness and cushion, and it estimates how many decibels a child's jump would make in the flat below — and plays the sound at that level. Notice that upgrading the cushion makes the chair scrape plummet while the child's jumping barely moves: that is the heart of this problem.

```map /embed/floor-2026-en.html 4:5
Floor lab: choose the structure (wall-bearing or column), slab thickness (150, 180, 210 or 250 mm) and resilient layer (none, standard or high-end), and a cross-section shows the impact travelling through the structure into the flat below, while the estimated levels of a child's jump (heavy impact) and a dragged chair (light impact) are placed on the grade-1-to-4 scale. Press the speaker buttons to hear synthesised thuds and scrapes scaled to those levels. The numbers are a toy model anchored to field measurements (KICT 2024 literature review, LH slab-thickness data), not a performance prediction. A second tab, "The decibel ruler", lets you slide a level along a ruler marked with the legal limits (39 dB day, 34 dB night), the floor-impact grades (37, 41, 45, 49 dB) and annoyance-study results
```

## The rules chase the noise

The law has been chasing this problem for over twenty years. Before the 2000s, apartment floor slabs were around 120 mm. The housing construction standards were amended in 2003, and from 2004 Korea had legal limits on floor impact sound: 58 dB for light impact, 50 dB for heavy. In 2005 came the standard floor structures, setting minimum slab thicknesses of 210 mm for wall-bearing, 180 mm for flat-plate and 150 mm for column buildings. That the rules demanded the thickest floor from the wall-bearing type was itself the system admitting which structure has the worst noise problem.

![A timeline of inter-floor noise policy from 2003 to 2026. Marked events: floor-impact limits introduced in 2003–2004 (light 58 dB, heavy 50 dB); standard floor structures and pre-certification in 2005 (wall-bearing slab 210 mm); thickness and performance both required from 2013; the audit board flagging the pre-certification loophole in 2019; post-construction testing from August 2022 (measured in finished flats, 49 dB for both, rubber-ball source); living-noise limits tightened in January 2023 (39 dB day, 34 dB night); the December 2023 announcement of "no approval for failing buildings", marked as still not legislated; July 2024 duties to notify buyers of test results and a 115% height-limit bonus for slabs of 250 mm or more; and the November 2026 proposal to extend the 49 dB rule to villas and officetels.](/uploads/71b79e835464c131.webp =720)

But the rules had a hole in them: performance was certified in advance, in a laboratory. Floor systems that earned grade 1 in the lab were routinely built to a failing standard on site, and in 2019 the Board of Audit and Inspection called out the loophole. So since August 2022 the testing happens after construction. In the finished building, 2–5% of the units are sampled and measured for real, and the limit was unified at 49 dB for both light and heavy impact. The measuring device changed too. For years heavy impact was measured with the "bang machine", which drops a car tyre; its impact force of roughly 4,500 newtons is far more violent than a child's footfall and was criticised for overstating the 63 Hz band. Now a 2.5 kg rubber ball is dropped from one metre — about 1,500 newtons, much closer to an actual jumping child.

The field data is honest about where floors stand today. In the measurements compiled by KICT in 2024, wall-bearing floors with 180 mm slabs averaged 50.6 dB of heavy impact sound; wall-bearing 210 mm floors, 47.5 dB; flat-plate 250 mm floors, 45.6 dB; and 275 mm floors, 44.5 dB. Laid on the grade chart, most are grade 3 or 4 — scraping by. Grade 1, 37 dB or below, is still a distant number.

![A bar chart with structure and slab thickness on the horizontal axis and heavy impact sound in decibels on the vertical axis. Bars read wall-bearing 180 mm at 50.6 dB, wall-bearing 210 mm at 47.5 dB, flat-plate 250 mm at 45.6 dB and flat-plate 275 mm at 44.5 dB, drawn over background bands for grade 1 (37 dB or less), grade 2 (41 dB), grade 3 (45 dB) and grade 4 (49 dB). Most bars sit in the grade 3–4 bands. The source is given as the field-measurement averages (79 flats on 14 sites) in KICT's 2024 literature review.](/uploads/b63ac446cbed25a3.webp =720)

The rules are still moving — and stalled in one place. In December 2023 the government announced that new apartments failing the noise standard would be required to carry out remedial construction, and would be denied final approval until they passed. But that requires amending the Housing Act, and three years after the announcement it has not passed the National Assembly; a bill turning the remedial-work "recommendation" into an order was tabled again this April. What is actually in force dates from July 2024: builders must notify buyers of the test results, on pain of a ₩5 million fine, and a building with floors 250 mm or thicker earns a relaxation of its height limit to 115%. The programmes for existing buildings have a dismal record. A scheme lending up to ₩3 million per household for certified noise-reducing mats was budgeted at ₩15 billion and ended up supporting 44 cases — ₩111 million; the remodelling loan drew zero applications in two years. Nobody fixes their floor with borrowed money. This month, a proposed amendment was pre-announced that would extend the 49 dB requirement to the blind spots so far — small multi-household buildings and officetels.

## The upstairs on screen

Outside all these numbers, there are feelings. Phone consultations at the Ministry of Environment's Neighbour Relations Centre jumped 60.9%, from 26,257 in 2019 to 42,250 in 2020, the year everyone stayed home; the past five years total more than 210,000. By a tally of police data compiled by the Citizens' Coalition for Economic Justice, major violent crimes arising from inter-floor noise rose from 11 in 2016 to 110 in 2021 (the police do not keep an official category for this, so the figure is an advocacy-group count). With that much raw material, the storytellers were never going to pass it by.

And indeed, last year Korean cinemas and streaming services filled up with inter-floor noise films. "Wonjung Villa" in December 2024; the Ma Dong-seok-produced comedy "The Unemployed Apartment" in February; the horror-thriller "Noise" with Lee Sun-bin in June; Netflix's "84 Square Meters" in July; and in late November "The People Upstairs", directed by and starring Ha Jung-woo. Five films in one year is not a subject. It is a genre.

| Work | Year | How it used inter-floor noise |
|---|---|---|
| Sleep | 2023 | A husband's sleepwalking becomes the night noise, and the ghost of the downstairs neighbour who used to complain about noise becomes the horror |
| Wonjung Villa | 2024 | An inter-floor noise thriller |
| The Unemployed Apartment | 2025 | A comedy about hunting down the culprit — the director's own noise ordeal was the starting point |
| Noise | 2025 | Real-world horror in which a noise-tormented sister disappears — everyone hears it, no one takes responsibility |
| 84 Square Meters | 2025 | A flat bought with everything borrowed becomes a noise hell, and the hero is accused of being the noisemaker |
| The People Upstairs | 2025 | A black comedy in which the downstairs couple invites the upstairs couple to dinner (a remake of Spain's "Sentimental") |

The box-office numbers confirmed how widely the subject is felt. "84 Square Meters" reached third place among Netflix's non-English films worldwide within three days and entered the top 10 in 40 countries. At the production press conference, director Kim Tae-joon explained his choice of subject by saying "some 80% of the population lives in conditions where inter-floor noise is unavoidable" (a director's remark, not a statistic). Even the title is about structure. Because Korea's "national housing" threshold was drawn at 85 m² of exclusive area, builders mass-produced the 84 m² unit; that "national standard flat" is the default middle-class home, drawing 55.5% of all first-rank housing applications in the first half of 2023. The irony of the dream floor plan becoming the stage of the noise war fits in the four characters of the title.

What these films agree on is interesting: the culprit stays out of sight. In "Sleep", in "Noise", in "84 Square Meters", the protagonists never quite know where the sound is coming from, and the suspicion does the damage. Low-frequency sound running through walls hides its direction, and in real life too, the thud you swore came from upstairs sometimes came from the flat diagonally above. The reason the inter-floor noise story cleaves so naturally to thriller and horror is that this noise physically conceals its source. The Spanish original shows the problem isn't uniquely Korean — in North America's wood-frame apartments, floor noise is a top-tier complaint too — but few countries can sell this genre like one where half the population lives in concrete wall-bearing flats.

## The people building quieter floors

So what are the builders doing? Around 2022, when post-construction testing arrived, the big construction firms started spending real money on noise research. In May 2022 Samsung C&T opened a dedicated inter-floor noise research facility in Yongin — "Raemian Goyoan Lab", four storeys plus a basement, 2,380 m² — an experimental building with slabs of different thicknesses on different floors, to measure for real. Hyundai E&C earned grade 1 for both light and heavy impact with five floor systems and applied them commercially for the first time at a complex in Daechi-dong, Seoul. DL E&C's "D-Silent" floor, which inserts vibration-isolating pads between the base mortar and the slab, has been developed up to grade 1; and the floor system GS E&C built with LX Hausys posted the industry's lowest figures at the LH quality test — 31 dB heavy, 27 dB light. In August this year Posco E&C won post-construction-test certification for "Anullim R", a technology designed for remodelling — welcome because it is for the thin floors of buildings that already exist, not just new ones. LH has announced plans to apply grade-1-level floors (37 dB) and 25 cm slabs to public housing from 2025.

Reservations are in order. The "industry first grade 1" claims all rest on each company's own press releases, and before grade 1 floors become the standard fit-out of ordinary apartments there is a mountain called cost. But the direction is clear. Twenty years ago you only had to pass the test in a laboratory; now a rubber ball is dropped in the finished flat. Technology moves when measurement becomes honest.

## Where AI can step in

As is this series' habit, I end by looking for where AI fits. The misery of inter-floor noise lies as much in unprovability as in the sound itself. What the sound is, where it comes from, how loud it is — the downstairs household can prove none of it alone. All three are becoming things machines do well.

Start with what the sound is. Researchers at KICT recorded 24 hours of audio in the living rooms of three apartments with actual noise complaints, labelled 1,515 sound clips — footsteps, dragged furniture, hammering, dropped objects — and trained a convolutional neural network. It distinguished sixteen classes of sound with 95.27% accuracy (PLOS ONE, 2020). That used to be a human's job: travel out, listen, judge — slow, costly, and different from judge to judge. A Seoul National University team reported a model that identified the kind of sound with 99.5% accuracy and the position it came from with 95.3%, trained on two thousand noise events from one building (Applied Sciences, 2019). Single-building results, so generalisation is still homework — but it takes dead aim at this problem's nastiest trait, the sound that hides its source.

For how loud, there is a more interesting approach. Recording brings privacy with it; nobody is comfortable with an always-on microphone in the living room. So KICT's 2022 follow-up threw the microphone away. Using only the signals of vibration sensors attached to walls and floor, it predicted the noise level of upstairs footsteps with a mean error of 0.99 dB (Applied Acoustics). Record the noise without recording the sound. The same idea is entering real buildings. DL E&C's "D-Silence", applied since 2024, embeds vibration sensors in the walls; when vibration over the 39 dB reference occurs three times in ten seconds, the offending flat's own wallpad shows a caution, and at six times a warning. The upstairs learns before the downstairs comes up to knock. In a residents' survey, 78% were positive. Hyundai E&C and Daewoo E&C offer similar alert systems. For now these are threshold alarms rather than learning models — but once sensors are installed, data accumulates, and accumulated data has always flowed in the same direction.

What about erasing the sound? Could the noise cancelling in your earphones hang from a ceiling? In 2023 a Korean team tried it in a laboratory: an adaptive-filter active noise control system aimed at heavy impact sound in the 40–500 Hz band cut about 4 dB (Journal of the Korean Society of Disaster and Security). That is one grade's worth, not nothing — but the road is long. Earphones only need to quiet the small space of an ear canal; a living room is tens of cubic metres, low-frequency cancellation holds only in small zones around the microphones and speakers, and a thud gives no warning of when it will come.

And then there is mediation — the part closest to the notebook's question of how to reconcile two homes. By figures reported this September, of 148 inter-floor noise cases filed with the central apartment-management dispute mediation committee over the past three years, 13 ended in agreement: 8.8%. The agency that measures (the Neighbour Relations Centre) and the agency that mediates are different bodies, so gathering the noise diary and the measurement records falls to the exhausted parties themselves. A dedicated AI counselling or mediation service for inter-floor noise, as far as I could confirm, does not yet exist. Which means this seat is empty. A machine that calmly logs the kind, time and size of each sound before feelings harden; that points out "not that flat — the bathroom pipes two floors up"; that lays both sides' records on the same scale so a conversation can start — every piece of that already sits in a lab somewhere. In the middle of the fight, each side trusts its own ears as evidence. The role of the impartial recorder standing between them may be a job better suited to a machine than to a person.

There is also the design stage. Today, floor impact sound is measured only after the building is finished. Physics models and machine-learning studies at home and abroad are trying to predict performance from the drawings alone; in overseas work on timber floors, neural-network predictions of impact sound still err by up to 5 dB. With grades spaced 4 dB apart, that needs tightening before it is useful. The nationwide field data that post-construction testing keeps accumulating will be its training material.

## Closing

Back to the notebook's question: the wisest way to reconcile two households at war over inter-floor noise. From today's walk through it, the answer has three layers.

The best answer is to build homes that give them nothing to fight over. Korea's inter-floor noise is not, at bottom, a problem of difficult neighbours; it is the compound interest on a decision, made over decades, to save 30 cm of storey height and some construction cost by letting the walls carry the house. A number like 98.5% means it is a problem of structure, not character. Thicker floors, grade-1 cushioning systems, and a rule that checks them with a rubber ball in the finished flat are slowly winding that decision back.

In the homes already built, the answer is knowing first. If the upstairs learns how many decibels its footsteps make below before the doorbell rings, many fights never start. That is what the sensors in the wall and the wallpad notification are for.

And for the two households already at war, the answer is to hand them records instead of feelings. What sound, when, how loud. The human ear is a desperate witness to suffering, but it has never served as a language of mediation. An AI that names the sound, locates its source and writes down its size can be the first witness between the two homes that belongs to neither side. Reconciliation doesn't begin with an apology; it begins with both sides looking at the same facts.

*A Page for Today* is a series in which I open my idea notebook at random and lay the day's thoughts on whatever line I find there. Today's line was "What would be the wisest way to reconcile two households at war over inter-floor noise?"

- Structure and statistics: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, structural types of apartment complexes of 500+ households (2017 parliamentary audit) · Statistics Korea, 2023 Population and Housing Census · Economist Korea, Sep 2023 · Newsway, Oct 2024 · National Archives, the Two Million Homes programme
- Sound and floors: LH housing research institute materials on slab thickness · Park et al., "A literature survey and residents' survey on floor impact sound insulation by structural type", J. Acoust. Soc. Korea 43(6), 2024 · Korean Society for Noise and Vibration Engineering and Architectural Institute of Korea studies on cushion resonance (EPS 63 Hz, EVA 125 Hz) · KCC central lab ceiling air-gap experiment (2013) · J. Acoust. Soc. Korea 2023 (bang machine to rubber ball)
- Policy: Housing Construction Standards decree (2003 amendment) · MOLIT, post-construction testing (Aug 2022) and inter-floor noise resolution plan briefing (Dec 2023) · Housing Act amendment (passed Dec 2023, in force Jul 2024) · Board of Audit and Inspection, 2019 (via The Scoop series, Jun 2026) · Munhwa Ilbo and SBS Biz on the mat and remodelling loan programmes · Nov 2026 pre-announcement extending the floor-impact standard
- Complaints and incidents: Ministry of Environment and Korea Environment Corporation, Neighbour Relations Centre statistics (phone consultations) · Hankyung, Oct 2025 (running and walking sounds, 68.6%) · Citizens' Coalition for Economic Justice statement, Jun 2023 (violent-crime count) · Money Today, Sep 2026 (13 settlements out of 148 mediations)
- Films: News1, Jun 2025, "Inter-floor noise, cinema's new stock subject" · release and press-conference coverage of 84 Square Meters, Sleep, Noise, The People Upstairs, The Unemployed Apartment and Wonjung Villa · KB knowledge hub on the 84 m² "national flat"
- Builders: ET News, May 2022 (Goyoan Lab) · Asia Business Daily, Dec 2024 (Daechi Edelrui) · CEO Score Daily, Oct 2024 (H Silent, D-Silent, D-Silence) · Smart Today (GS and LX Hausys, 31 dB) · Financial News, Aug 2026 (Anullim R)
- AI: Shin, Park and Kim, PLOS ONE 15(12), 2020 (CNN classification, 95.27%) · Choi et al., Applied Sciences 9(18), 2019 (type 99.5%, position 95.3%) · Shin et al., Applied Acoustics, 2022 (vibration-based prediction, MAE 0.99 dB) · Kim et al., J. Korean Soc. Disaster and Security 16(3), 2023 (ANC, 4 dB) · NIOSH smartphone sound-app studies · Lund University ANN studies on timber floors

