oosioo
책상 위 다이어리에 펜으로 적는 손과 커피·크루아상. 「인사평가와 퇴사 · 2편 — 리더가 할 일은 판을 까는 것」 제목을 얹은 표지
SeriesNotes from the Office · Ep. 2

Performance Reviews and Attrition (2) — A Leader's Job Is to Set the Table

Here's a rundown of four things leaders should ask in August, and two preconditions for becoming someone who sets the table. Delegation you can start today, but consistency only proves itself over time.

· SYSOP · 42 views
▶ This post as a video (Korean) · 4:40Watch on YouTube
Shorts (Korean) · 5
8월, 리더가 물어야 할 4가지
뒤집힌 평가, 무너진 기준
바쁜 팀장이 지치는 이유
다들 괜찮다는 팀의 비밀
묻고, 적고, 지키는 리더

In the previous piece, I talked about the distrust surrounding performance reviews. I ended by saying that leadership and management ultimately need to change, so this time I want to write about what leaders should actually do. As you might guess, management tends not to change as easily as we'd like.

Four Things to Ask in August

Two people sitting across from each other at a round table by a window, talking

The video I'm referencing was posted around August, and it suggests a few things leaders should check in with employees about around this time of year.

  1. Are the goals set at the start of the year still valid?
  2. What percentage of the way through are we now?
  3. Are there any blockers or difficulties the leader could help resolve?
  4. What do they want to accomplish in the time remaining this year?

I think this checklist accounts for more than it might seem to at first glance.

Annual Plans Don't Always Hold Up

At startups especially, an organization's goals and direction can shift fairly often, so annual plans frequently stop matching reality. In these cases, it's worth regularly revisiting the team's goals and direction, discussing and adjusting them together with the team.

I used to check in on individual work weekly to keep everyone aligned on direction, and it turned out to help quite a bit. I kept records of these weekly check-ins and compiled them into monthly evaluations. Once you have a traceable record, comparative evaluation gets much easier too.

The Person Who Sets the Table

A photo of a hand writing something down in a notebook

What stood out to me most in the checklist were items 3 and 4. If a leader is someone who sets the table so that team members can do their work better, the organization is generally running well. There seem to be roughly two preconditions and principles behind this.

First, Proper Delegation and Motivation

Good leaders need to spend a lot of time making important decisions, and it's best if they can delegate hands-on work to their team members as much as possible. Ordinary, busy managers often can't fully trust their team or fail to build up their capabilities, so they end up running every meeting and every task themselves — busy and burned out.

When I first became a manager, I was genuinely overwhelmed and exhausted. But at some point, I started delegating most of the work and shifted to making bigger decisions from a broader perspective, setting direction, and solving the problems team members ran into.

Encouraging team members to develop their own capabilities while wanting to do things that align with the organization's direction, and building an environment where those goals benefit not just the individual but the company as well — that turned out to be more valuable in the long run than just clearing out immediate tasks. Of course, getting there takes effort on everyone's part, but then again, nothing worthwhile happens without effort.

Second, Holding to the Standards You've Stated

The second is consistency. The standards stated at the start of the year need to still be standing at the end of the year — obvious once you put it into words, but easy to overlook.

Thinking back on why that spreadsheet from my earlier piece was such a problem, it wasn't just that the scoring was off. The bigger issue was that team leads entered evaluations every month, only for a handful of executives to overturn them at the end. Once it gets overturned once, nobody treats that standard as a standard anymore. The same goes for team leads. If you know the score you gave is going to get erased anyway, what grounds do you have left to talk to your team members?

Item 3 on the checklist runs into this same problem. Telling people to speak up about blockers or difficulties only gets a real response if the person saying it has actually cleared something out of the way before. Let it slide once or twice, and after that everyone just says they're fine. Setting the table, in the end, comes down to repeatedly doing what you said you'd do until it accumulates — not building one more system.

I think this part is harder than delegation. Delegation is something you can decide to start today, but consistency only proves itself over time.

Closing Thoughts

In the end, what a leader can actually do doesn't seem all that grand. Ask those four questions at the right time, write down the answers, and do what you said you'd do. It looks less impressive than building a new system, but it turns out to be harder and take longer.

There's not much to be done if someone doesn't get a good review because they lack the skills. But we can cut down on the cases where someone with real skills leaves simply because no one properly explained things to them. No matter how well-designed a system is, in the end, an organization's performance and trajectory come down to how the leader holds the wheel and which direction they steer.

Hope everyone keeps at it, wherever you are.

Read this series from the start: Notes from the Office.