oosioo
Cover showing that the generation-gap label is an illusion, exaggerated beyond reality
SeriesNotes from the Office · Ep. 33

We Are All the Same (2) — The Illusion of Generations

Gen Z, the old guard: we often blame conflict on generations. But the data says generational differences are far smaller than we think. The real problem seems to have been communication, not generations.

· SYSOP · 18 views

When conflict breaks out, we tend to reach for a convenient name. "That's just how Gen Z is..." "That's just how the old guard is..." We try to explain the other person with a generational label. But a label is as dangerous as it is convenient.

What the Data Says

Generational differences are much smaller than we think. One research team compared the work attitudes of nearly 20,000 people by generation and found that meaningful differences all but disappeared. Even Pew Research Center, a byword for polling, decided to use generational labels sparingly, on the grounds that much generational content is closer to "marketing myths dressed up as research" and reinforces harmful stereotypes. The US National Academies went further and stated plainly that sorting people by generation tends to breed bias and age discrimination. The reason is that the differences between individuals within one generation are as large as the differences between generations.

What's interesting is why this illusion refuses to go away. Scholars say generational differences are "socially constructed." The press writes stories about "what this generation is like," marketers sell things under the label, and even researchers look at their data through that frame, so modest differences inflate one another. In fact, much of what looks like a generational difference is better explained by age, that is, by life stage, or by the mood of the times.

Korea is much the same. In one survey, people said generational conflict was "serious," yet in the same breath said its real nature wasn't about generations at all.

What people agreed with in one surveyShare
The gap between regular and non-regular workers is bigger than the generation gap65%
The media exaggerates generational conflict62%
It's really a problem of rich and poor, not of generations60%

One sociologist went so far as to title a book There Is No Such Generation. Only one or two in ten Koreans born in the 1960s went to university, he pointed out, so lumping them all together as "that generation, the establishment" is an illusion from the start.

A bar diagram comparing the small differences between generations with the large individual differences within a generation

Not the Label, Not the Title

Removing the label isn't enough. Neither is changing the form. Korean companies have spent more than twenty years tearing down job titles. People started adding "-nim" to each other's names, using English names, and flattening ranks into "manager." Yet one company, after twenty years of "-nim," still kept rank titles on business cards, and another reportedly brought in English names only to find communication got more tangled and went back. Changing what people called each other didn't make hierarchy disappear. The people involved know this. In one survey, six in ten younger respondents said lumping them together as "MZ" was inappropriate, and that dividing people by generation actually fuels conflict.

So what should change? In one survey, companies said abolishing titles had done little good, and pointed instead to how decisions, evaluations and rewards are made. The structure, not the shell of what people are called, was what needed fixing. Changing the form is easy, but easy fixes didn't solve the hard problem.

Once you peel off the generational label, what's left? Communication. At its core the conflict was less about generations and more about not knowing each other's situation. People thirty years apart made a good team when they understood each other, and people of the same age from the same school still clashed when they didn't.

In the next post I'll talk about a way to actually open up that communication: "interpreting."

Read this series from the start: Notes from the Office.